Cliff May, after squaring off against representatives of the ACLU, Center for Constitutional Rights and CAIR:
Prior to 9/11/01 there were at least 19 al-Qaeda members in the United States. They had committed no acts of terrorism. But they planned to. Members of our intelligence community evidently did not listen to the phone calls they made to, and received from, their employers abroad. Nor were their communications with one another monitored.
Most Americans probably believe that should have been done – that had it been done 3,000 Americans might not have been murdered. But the CCR, the ACLU and others are essentially saying that 9/11 was a fair price to pay to guarantee their idea of privacy rights. And if we have to pay that price again, so be it.
David Warren, in the context of Canada’s coming election, but the wider application is obvious:
It is very hard to be both a politician and a Christian, to be faithful both to party and God. I know this from having met a few Christian politicians. I know it better from experiencing my own reactions, when I get into a tumbledown political fight. The desire to cut corners, to misrepresent, to exploit ignorance and subvert reason, to play to the lowest motives in one’s audience while pretending to play to the highest – these are not temptations only for others. Nor can they ever be restricted to one political party.
Politics is ritualized combat (the alternative being unritualized), and it is very hard, on the battlefield of an election campaign, to distinguish sin from sinner. Which is paradoxically why it is so important to have a clear sense of the devil. For without the devil, our opponents become devils, and instead of fighting against their errors, we fight only to destroy.
Comments