The list of Hugo nominees for 2008 has just appeared. Some of the choices of vox populi surprise, and a couple appall, me, which isn’t any different from years past.
At a recent con, I heard Mike Resnick bemoan the vast falling off of the readership of the print SF mags, which today have about a tenth of the circulation of 20 years ago. Even though he himself edits the on-line Jim Baen’s Universe, he urged the audience to subscribe to Asimov’s, Analog and F&SF. The nominee list shows one good reason why: Of the 15 short fiction candidates, 11 appeared in the print magazines (four only in anthologies, none on-line), and one of the novels (Rollback by Robert Sawyer) was serialized in Analog. They may be short of readers, but the old mags still print the best stuff.
I’ll reserve comments for later but do want to express my delight that Diana Glyer’s The Company They Keep: C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien as Writers in Community got a Best Related Book nomination. I can pretend that my review was responsible.
Thanks, Tom! Of course your review is entirely responsible for the nomination-- how else would so many fans have gotten the real scoop? It's rare for Tolkien and Lewis to get this kind of attention; maybe this will encourage more fans to find out just how interesting these guys are. all best, Diana
Posted by: Diana Glyer | Friday, March 21, 2008 at 02:53 PM